A Bay Shore Institution Since 1989
From Our Kitchen
Crafted with passion, served with pride. Discover the flavors that keep our guests coming back.
Creamy chowder, fresh clams, bacon, herbs
Fresh lobster salad, butter-toasted roll, chips
Oysters, clams, shrimp, cocktail sauce, mignonette
What People Say
Don't just take our word for it — hear from our wonderful guests.
"Been coming to Nicky's for 20 years! Best clam chowder on Long Island and the lobster rolls are always fresh. A true Bay Shore treasure."
"Perfect waterfront dining! The raw bar is always fresh and the fish & chips are crispy and delicious. Love the nautical atmosphere."
"Nicky's is a classic! Great for families, reasonable prices, and the fried clams are the best I've ever had. A Bay Shore institution."
